The 5th generation of gaming consoles had a ton of yearly sports titles, as well as the arcade style sports games across the board.
I spent most of my sports gaming time on either the PS1 or the N64, as they had more advanced controllers for a more realistic approach to a sports game.
On N64, I frequently played NFL QB Club 98 as the graphics were so realistic at the time that it was mind blowing, and I was also playing quite a bit of NBA In The Zone 98, while my brother played Ken Griffey Jr’s Slugfest to death. As I look back now, I wasn’t playing EA Sports titles on the N64 for some reason, although I remember the Madden games being unplayable to me on the N64.
PS1 is definitely my pick from the bunch! I started out with the 989 Sports Launch titles like Gameday, Face Off, and In The Zone, later moving on to NBA Shoot Out that year. The next year, I played Madden 97 a lot, but also playing the shit out of NCAA Gamebreaker and Gameday 97, but I played a ton of Triple Play 97 as well which switched me back over the EA Sports games.
The next year I was big into NFL Gameday 98, and started playing a lot of NFL Blitz when it came to home consoles. I had it on PS1, but all of my friends had it on N64 so that one is kind of a wash for this topic.
By 1999-2001 I was only playing EA Sports titles, and as I mentioned before, I never really played any on the N64, so PS1 got the lions share of my sports gaming during the 5th generation.