I could have sworn I posted on here, but I guess I didn't hit submit?
Anyway, I definitely had a few games I really, really liked in my younger days but to be honest, I have no clue if some of them were bad. My nostalgia glasses are over 20/20 today, so it's tough for me to be a fair judge. But, here's my list of games that I doubt others consider "classics" so they probably are just fair at best.
Cybernoid (NES) - Tough as nails and I could never get much further than the past stage. Still, I loved it.
Anticipation (NES) - Not a great party game once you memorized everything, but once my brother and I did learn all of the timed puzzles, it was usually a game of seeing who could tap the "OK" button fast enough to answer the questions.
Yo! Noid (NES) - I think others think this is a good game, I'm not sure, but I loved it a bunch. It was the only CAPCOM title I owned for the NES.
Star Voyager (NES) - I borrowed this from my uncle a lot. I really liked it, although I never ever really figured out the point of the game.
Stealth ATF (NES) - Ok, it's a fair game but what made it suck for me is I could almost never land the plane. So... I rarely made it past the first stage, or training even if that's what it was. Regardless, I enjoyed playing a game as a stealth fighter jet!
Wheel of Fortune (NES) - Same as Anticipation. This is a fine 8-bit version of the game, but once you've memorized all of the puzzles and can guess them after 2-3 letters are revealed, it's not fun. But I continued playing it anyway.
Lunar Pool (NES) - I still don't know why I enjoyed playing this game, usually lowering the friction to 0. It's an ok pool sim for the NES, but what I got into was just mucking around with the physics.
Sonic 2 (Game Gear) - Yeah, no. This is just not a great game. It's too hard. But it was my first game on my Game Gear so, dog gonnit, I logged tons of hours on it.
Star Gate (Game Gear) - It's a puzzle game. Probably not a bad one, but I bought it without even looking at the back of the box. I loved the movie, and the genesis port looked cool from commercials, so I assumed it'd be the same general game. Though I was at first disappointed with it being a puzzle game I did enjoy it regardless.
The Berenstein Bears (Game Gear) - This was a game my sister had, but once I had worn out all of my other platform games for the system, I borrowed this one. It's an easy enough game, but I still found it enjoyable for a light game.
Star Wars (Game Gear) - Ooooooh my gosh, I'm sure this is considered a bad game but I outright loved it. I never beat it, I don't think, but I got close and never tired of trying.
Jurassic Park (Game Gear) - I guess this one is good? I don't know. I loved it to much as a kid to objectively grade it.
Star Wars Rebel Assualt II (PS1) - My Dad bought this to give to me when he bought me my PS1 one Christmas. I have great love for this game because of it.
I expected Galaga to be in this year's tournament but I guess not because we're already playing a shooter.
Really curious what the finals will be. My guess is Rush n Attack for low score/progress. I hope not though.
The entire Paper Mario series and Mario & Luigi series. I started with Thousand Year Door and Superstar Saga, respectfully, and I don't get the hype. Went back to the first Paper Mario and it was ok. I left it feeling like I would just rather play Super Mario RPG.
Kingdom Hearts. I bought it new back in the day with paper route money and I tried to start that game so many times and it just never grabbed me. I gifted it to my little sister and she still adores the series. I'm still bitter about spending like a month of paper route money on it.
Modern sports titles. I like the 2K sports back in the day but haven't been interested in playing any sports titles in the last 15ish years.
Mortal Kombat / Killer Instinct. Even as a kid I didnt care for these series.
3D platformers. Mario 64/Sunshine/Odyssey, Donkey Kong 64, Croc, Banjo series, etc. I just never felt like platformers transitioned well into 3D and every series being a collect-a-thon is just not enjoyable